Playing Dumb
He held the guitar upside down. His hair was unkempt and his face scarred. He smelled like he’d skipped a few showers.
He scraped his nails down the guitar strings and produced a miserable sound.
The other kids laughed.
He wore a dumb smile on his face. He looked around the room at the other students. “What, did I do something wrong? I’m playing guitar.”
He banged the strings again and produced a worse sound. He was getting attention and he knew it. In the corner of the room the guard sank her head into her hands. She’d seen this song and dance before.
It’d been a long day. I’d gone from Bible study in Buckhead to a horticulture class in Columbus to guitar class in southeast Atlanta. I felt exhausted from all the driving and talking and guards and locks and prison cells. It’d been a long week, really.
I snatched the guitar out of his hands. My anger surprised him; it surprised me too. I flipped the guitar over the right way and plopped it on his knee. I grabbed his left hand and put it on the neck of the guitar. I told him to use his right hand to play the strings. “You can learn like everyone else, or you can sit here quietly. You choose.” I stepped back and chastised myself silently – how dare I be so angry. His face looked shocked, the other boys fell silent. They’d never seen me act this way.
Despite acknowledging my shortcoming, I couldn’t kick the feeling – I was still angry.
“Look,” I said. “I’m tired of teaching this same dumb song. Let’s learn this quickly and move on to something else.”
The boys sat up straight. Ten minutes later, they’d learned the tune. They made very few errors. I’ve never had a class learn that quickly.
We moved on to the next song, one much more challenging. They responded to the challenge and played beautifully.
“Let’s try something even harder,” I said. I played “All Apologies” by Nirvana, a tougher song I’d been practicing for a few days. The room erupted in laughter, “Nah, nah, nah, we ain’t ready for that,” they said.
We went back and reviewed both songs they’d learned. At the end of the hour, they all shook my hand and lined up for the door. I pulled the student who’d been playing dumb aside.
“I’m sorry for being mean, but I know you’re not dumb. I watched how quickly you learned both those songs. You aren’t dumb. Don’t play me. Don’t play others.”
He smiled. He’d been caught in the act and he knew it.
“I know, I know,” he said.
The holidays are the busiest time of year for youth detention centers across America. It’s not because kids are out of school and get in trouble. It’s not because they’re stealing gifts or robbing people either. The truth is a lot of kids will intentionally get locked up around the holidays because the youth detention center is better than home. Whether their home is unsafe or devoid of food or love, the youth detention center offers a reprieve to many of these children.
All this kid wanted was attention. He’s not a monster. He just wants to be seen.
May we see him – and each other - through the eyes of Jesus this holiday season.


